no, but on the forum a lot of people reported bridge filter issuedid you report this before?still bridge filter dosn't show any stats,
does it work and have only stats update problem or it doesn't work at all?
regards
Ros
Ros
no, but on the forum a lot of people reported bridge filter issuedid you report this before?still bridge filter dosn't show any stats,
does it work and have only stats update problem or it doesn't work at all?
regards
Ros
this function didn't work in any version before. including v4.17, that's why we removed it, until it can be fixed. so basically it doesn't matter for you if you use v5.2 or v4.17
yes, same question from me?, why this function removed?. we stuck on v.4.17 now.. im very glad v.5 userman, can breaking the voucher on to more than 3 voucher per paper, will saving the papers.
No, I have still a problem with the Logs under 5.2 - see here for 5.1yesIs usermanager working on this release?
The no working bridge filter was already reported from me to support. The open ticket is 2011041266000166. Already sent supout from v4.17 with working filters and v5.1 and v5.2 with filters don't working.you know that unreported issues can't be fixed. not all issues are easy to find by ourselves, that's why we also rely on our customers to report problems that they find.
The no working bridge filter was already reported from me to support. The open ticket is 2011041266000166. Already sent supout from v4.17 with working filters and v5.1 and v5.2 with filters don't working.you know that unreported issues can't be fixed. not all issues are easy to find by ourselves, that's why we also rely on our customers to report problems that they find.
Dear Normis, where im can get information about changelog on bootload firmware? im see on Our RB750 present 2.34 present 2.26 ???
What's new in 5.2 (2011-Apr-26 16:09):
*) fixed webfig;
*) console - fixed problem with supout file generation and export that
appeared in version 5.1, it was causing console to enter busy loop
on some boards;
*) ssh client - added source address and remote command options;
*) user manager - added /tool usermanager profile;
*) route - fixed problem with missing connected routes;
Wiki is a again OUTDATED. Where is 2.34?
Yes i have the same problem, but with 2 pppoe connections. The 2 pppoe connections disappear at random times.Anybody else having issues with 5.2 and PPTP losing connection? We have 2 remote sites connected into a main site via pptp. The PPTP connections from the remote sites seem to drop off randomly. To get connection back, we need to restart the pptp client at the remote sites. I've set up netwatch at the remote sites to do this automatically, but the remote sites have voip phones connected to the main site via eoip tunnels over the pptp link. When pptp goes out, so do the voip phones. So, the netwatch solution is a poor band aid.
We also had the router at the main site lock up this morning and had to reboot it manually.
Already sent supout.rif to support, just wondering if anybody else has seen similar behavior?
Is there any serial console output, when reboot fails? What packages are you using on those routers? Is there any watchdog configuration? Was this issue present before v5.2?I found some serious bug rebooting the devices. If you try to reboot by using winbox under System/Reboot, sometimes the router will shutdown instead of rebooting the device.
That happend about 6 times on different RB (450G,493G,1100 and x86). This is not happening erverytime but to often. Rebooting using terminal does not show this effect (so far).
Greetings from germany.
"/log print" after rebooti cant upgrade from my 5.orc11 to 5.2.
everyone has this problem do net install.i cant upgrade from my 5.orc11 to 5.2.
hello, i also facing the same problems with ROS 4.17 on my rb450, my configuration as hotspot usermanager, i set scheduler reboot in 1d 05:00:00 always, sometimes rb450 not responding/hangs, when scheduler running, if the problem occur i replug the adaptors power and then rb will reboot, i saw in the log router normally reboot, not showing "router was rebooted without proper shutdown (cause1)" with critical error, i not set watchdog, i leave it as default.Is there any serial console output, when reboot fails? What packages are you using on those routers? Is there any watchdog configuration? Was this issue present before v5.2?I found some serious bug rebooting the devices. If you try to reboot by using winbox under System/Reboot, sometimes the router will shutdown instead of rebooting the device.
That happend about 6 times on different RB (450G,493G,1100 and x86). This is not happening erverytime but to often. Rebooting using terminal does not show this effect (so far).
Greetings from germany.
hello, i also facing the same problems with ROS 4.17 on my rb450, my configuration as hotspot usermanager, i set scheduler reboot in 1d 05:00:00 always, sometimes rb450 not responding/hangs, when scheduler running, if the problem occur i replug the adaptors power and then rb will reboot, i saw in the log router normally reboot, not showing "router was rebooted without proper shutdown (cause1)" with critical error, i not set watchdog, i leave it as default.
yes, you already posted in the other topic, and I can see that Janis M. is working on it.Already done 2011050966000018
do you use dynamic routing? OSPF?Came in this morning after monitoring v5.2 all weekend with no obvious problems to find as soon as the users started routing traffic through it, it started jumping up and around >95% CPU load and started dropping packets.
I've dropped back to v5.0 to see if I can establish if it is a configuration change or the firmware change to 5.2 that has had the effect as we have a few mods over the past couple of weeks that might possibly be causing the issues.
I'll run with v5.0 through today and post some information later.
But I MUST do the following to get it working again on version 5.2:/routing filter add action=accept bgp-communities=65530:65530 chain=alpha-out disabled=no invert-match=no protocol=bgp
/routing filter add action=discard chain=alpha-out disabled=no invert-match=no
/routing filter add action=accept bgp-communities=65530:65530 chain=alpha-out disabled=no invert-match=no prefix=0.0.0.0/0 prefix-length=0-32 protocol=bgp
/routing filter add action=discard chain=alpha-out disabled=no invert-match=no
do you use dynamic routing? OSPF?Came in this morning after monitoring v5.2 all weekend with no obvious problems to find as soon as the users started routing traffic through it, it started jumping up and around >95% CPU load and started dropping packets.
I've dropped back to v5.0 to see if I can establish if it is a configuration change or the firmware change to 5.2 that has had the effect as we have a few mods over the past couple of weeks that might possibly be causing the issues.
I'll run with v5.0 through today and post some information later.
Yes its a month I have submitted many files but yet no answer!anyone having issues in v5.2, please generate supout.rif file at the moment of the problem, write a description, make a screenshot, and send it all to support.
you were instructed to adjust your EoIP configuration because it caused a loop. You didn't respond about that.Yes its a month I have submitted many files but yet no answer!anyone having issues in v5.2, please generate supout.rif file at the moment of the problem, write a description, make a screenshot, and send it all to support.
#2011041066000044 and
#2011032666000151
This memory leak in /ip route cache, has been present since 5. I remember having the issue even with RCs but don no which RC.
In addition, the EOIP disconnection was a symptom of router mulfunction and not the root cause! When router stops normal functionality, everything bad happens. EOIP interfaces disconnect/connect... bridges won't work. Ping times out... packet forwarding decreases.... pppoe interfaces disconnect...you were instructed to adjust your EoIP configuration because it caused a loop. You didn't respond about that.
In the same way that nobody benefits by you complaining about a customer complaining about bug in your software. Sometimes it seems you spend more time insulting people for the way they asked a question than actually trying to help them solve it. It is pretty obvious that things can't be communicated nearly as easily through the "support" system, so why not just offer a little official support on the forums.Other people on this forum have no benefit if you just complain and don't inform MikroTik
normis, we all do agree we should not complain here.glucz here is complaining that he didn't receive an answer to his ticket. In fact, the latest mail in the ticket was a question to him, which he didn't answer. That's why there is no progress on the issue in his specific case. I am only talking about him and his ticket right now.
I'm just interested Is there a way to increase "max-cache-size" ?...
[admin@MikroTik] > system resource print
uptime: 1d2h24m17s
version: "5.2"
free-memory: 232320KiB
total-memory: 270224KiB
architecture-name: "x86"
board-name: "x86"
platform: "MikroTik"
[admin@MikroTik] > ip route cache print
cache-size: 29487
max-cache-size: 65536
...
Here is another one after just 1 day 15 hours
[admin@MikroTik] > system resource print
uptime: 1d15h17m24s
version: "5.2"
free-memory: 219892KiB
total-memory: 256280KiB
architecture-name: "x86"
board-name: "x86"
platform: "MikroTik"
[admin@MikroTik] > ip route cache print
cache-size: 32767
max-cache-size: 32768
[admin@MikroTik] >
As I understand you have the same RAM size on both routers , but max-cache-size for routers is different.It seems like that the max cache size depends on the RAM in the router.
..
I have currently 4 routers running v5 which 2 of them have this route cache memory problem.No. They are all different. Whatever was available at the time.
Whoever else is also having route cache problems: Are you using tarpit actions in firewall rules?
I picked 2 MT750's off the shelf and am tring to build the minimum required rules and services to replicate the problem.
Thanks
GL
I' realy sorry ( ), but what is the difference betweenNo. They are all different.
GL
Glucz,I' realy sorry ( ), but what is the difference betweenNo. They are all different.
GL
total-memory: 270224KiB and total-memory: 256280KiB ???
Looks like both routers has 256Mb RAM.
My memory usage graph always showed slight memory increase. Even on the routers without this tarpit rule and of course these routers were stable in functionality.Yes. I can too confirm after 16 hours that route cache is now stable. So tarpit seems to leak into route cache.
GL
So I mention this again, what about a public facing bug-tracker? This would solve all these problems mentioned. We (the paying customers) will be able to keep track of bugs / features on our own time, and always have a place to reference when we ask a question about a bug/feature. This would solve the endless forum postings about 'ticket xyz, what is status?'.It is too often that people post angry messages like "when is this going to be fixed" because they assumed somebody reported this somewhere, but actually all of them are just waiting, and nothing is posted to the forum or to support. I am simply encouraging everyone to make those supout.rif files and participate to get problems fixed.
I was not able to repeat it. What architecture is the PPPoE server and client? Any specific configuration?I installed 5.2 on a pppoe (bras) mk router.
Till now I see a bug. in PPP, active connection you can see new connecting pppoe client uptime starts from 39seconds and starts decreasing till reaching 0, then starts increasing! So funny
So it's user "yyy" connect. you can see it's alive for 39, 38, 37, 36, .... , 0 , 1, 2 ,.... uptime!
It seems it's like starting timer from -40seconds
I was not able to repeat it. What architecture is the PPPoE server and client? Any specific configuration?I installed 5.2 on a pppoe (bras) mk router.
Till now I see a bug. in PPP, active connection you can see new connecting pppoe client uptime starts from 39seconds and starts decreasing till reaching 0, then starts increasing! So funny
So it's user "yyy" connect. you can see it's alive for 39, 38, 37, 36, .... , 0 , 1, 2 ,.... uptime!
It seems it's like starting timer from -40seconds
Please describe this problem in more details.There is some serious issue with pppoe connectivity in 5.2 & 4.17.
I downgraded to 5.0rc4 all issue solved but rc4 UM is not stable
BTW, I netinstalled 5.2 on a RB433 and at two RB450 because they had 0.3 ... 0.5% badblocks with the built in ROS (4.11 I guess). Even formatted NAND from boot menu (via RS232 console) to "zero" this readings.bad blocks 4.x,5.2> 0% ........ install RouterOS 5.3 (distib. 17.05.) bad blocks 4,2% ... RB433UAH
You are absolutely correct. When the router reached a higher uptime no more of this issue.I was not able to repeat it. What architecture is the PPPoE server and client? Any specific configuration?I installed 5.2 on a pppoe (bras) mk router.
Till now I see a bug. in PPP, active connection you can see new connecting pppoe client uptime starts from 39seconds and starts decreasing till reaching 0, then starts increasing! So funny
So it's user "yyy" connect. you can see it's alive for 39, 38, 37, 36, .... , 0 , 1, 2 ,.... uptime!
It seems it's like starting timer from -40seconds
I have seen a similar thing with OVPN uptime. I was able to make a screenshot and send it to support with supout. The issue is that the counter doesn't start from 0, but instead it will count from the current uptime value of ROS ... So In my case it said that the uptime was 19hrs ... I guess if the uptime value is large enough and the counter's underlying variable is unsigned, I can see this causing a backward count, but the initial value would be something random.