MikroTik

kemerovo

... we need to live with that fact ... read a post # 32 did I read your reference, tuning I did not find there, for what you it it was copied me??? ps it is unnecessary to pretend to be whatever you understood, you all had understood, limitation a multicaste will give nothing, will correct a proble...

kemerovo

can there be petition will accelerate a process and adequate answers for the questions of users???

kemerovo

If you filter multicast on port 3,4 then of course it will not go to clients connected to those ports. It's not exactly clear what you want to set up and why you need those filters. if is a question not quite clear you, why you write an answer?? look http://forum.mikrotik.com/viewtopic.php?t=62073 ...

kemerovo

When you disable switch configuration and add all slave ports to the bridge, then igmp-proxy should send multicast streams only on those bridge ports where client, that joined the multicast group, is connected. So bridge filters are not needed. once again if will I filter multicastes for example on...

kemerovo

the flow goes on all ports , the CPU load is increased to 80 , the router crashes , filtering does not help It surely goes to all ports, since you have one master port and the other slaves. Filtering does not work on slave ports, only on masters, so your filter rules do not work as expected. If you...

kemerovo

Open a new ticket with support with attached supout file after the crash. And simply do not mention anything about igmp snooping in that mail

sent, Ticket#2016090222000151

kemerovo

As far as I remember information already was provided and you already started to use it? Here are the configuration example again http://wiki.mikrotik.com/wiki/Manual:Routing/IGMP-Proxy#Examples http://www.picshare.ru/uploads/160901/Jx1c27gQBi.jpg the flow goes on all ports , the CPU load is increa...

kemerovo

As It was determined in other topics you created, you don't even need feature you are requesting. IGMP snooping is for switches, but you are trying to route Multicast streams over your router, in this case IGMP-proxy should be used which RouterOS already supports. OK, if you do not need it , give m...

kemerovo

In these cases is official answer always the same: when it will be then it will be. If you are not willing to wait, obtain devices of other manufacturers that are you sure will provide whole set of features you need. there are exceptions in all of rules, therefore I ask to do an exception and name ...

kemerovo

... and that we may work on it in future.

and more concrete? in a year, two? or three?

kemerovo

At the moment we read complaints of the grumbler. If you want help from us just ask for it.

nobody forces you to read it

kemerovo

If you need user help, other users may be glad to offer it. If not, don't post, that is your choice, but refrain from dragging us in your war on this forum.

at the moment I do not see help users and answer mikrotik

kemerovo

helpdesk, instead of helping to block my ip adress in this forum

kemerovo

hink it is somehow our fault, and we have to hear about your issues every day?
Write to support, not here. As said, this is an user forum.

if reading my posts , you would see that the support staff does not respond to them

kemerovo

we don't have access to your conversations with Support

I do not need your advice , I need an official response , when there will be the realization of a normal iptv

kemerovo

I am afraid you haven't described any problem, just that the router was rebooted by the watchdog. It could be even correct, none knows how you have set it.

supout.rif send 16/05/2016
Ticket#2016051666000086

kemerovo

our network of 25 computers and 1 console ror IPTV startup problems begin consoles winbox does not respond, router rebooted by watchdog, user user SQL not respond when will it work? Why should I put multiple routers for normal ?? I will write about this problem EVERY DAY until you decide to choose. ...

kemerovo

Check your discovery interfaces

all enable

kemerovo

2 times displayed the same device , in red , how to correct to display one ???

kemerovo

see this http://forum.mikrotik.com/viewtopic.php?f=19&t=102828&p=544337#p543365 ordinary users need a 1 router , rather than 2-3 . Why do you not understand? Most uses quick setup for the Internet and TV . but the TV does not work, it is very upsetting . I repeat the question that was asked...

kemerovo

If your TV works fine with a device that has no IGMP snooping, only proxy, are you sure you need Snooping at all? It looks like you are not really sure what causes the problem and how to solve it. Maybe start from beginning and test other approaches. I do not have TV , I have 2 laptops and a smart...

kemerovo

If for your IPTV IGMP proxy is enough then it is already supported in RouterOS http://wiki.mikrotik.com/wiki/Manual:Routing/IGMP-Proxy For this instruction does not work as it should work! increased CPU load on all ports increased activity and as a consequence the local network does not operate pro...

kemerovo

why not answer my question ?

kemerovo

Answer is in the second post.

is not the answer , it is an evasion .
More specifically , you can ?

kemerovo

That thing does NOT support IGMP snooping, it only supports IGMP proxy. My question regarding $35 device was specifically about IGMP snooping (please see what was quoted/referred to there).

what's the difference? this router normally shows IPTV

kemerovo

http://forum.mikrotik.com/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=62073&hilit=igmp+snooping question must necessarily be repeated 2 times ??? can be answered yes or no , and not throw the link . I need a clear answer as to what version of it will work . response when normal will operate IPTV , I still have not...

kemerovo

Easy solution - do not make any expectations :) We have already posted from time to time, that the biggest change is under the hood (minor kernel upgrade). There is no new GUI or anything. We are also working on a new routing engine. Actually we are making really cool stuff even in v6. Look at the ...

kemerovo

Which exact $35 model are you talking about? Can you please provide some references? Thanks.

http://www.tp-link.com/baltic/products/ ... 741ND.html

kemerovo

Easy solution - do not make any expectations :) We have already posted from time to time, that the biggest change is under the hood (minor kernel upgrade). There is no new GUI or anything. We are also working on a new routing engine. Actually we are making really cool stuff even in v6. Look at the ...

kemerovo

I will remind you once a week if you do not take into account the wishes of customers

kemerovo

most probably IGMP-snooping will not be available in RouterOS 6.x. However, if you can, you could try to create tunnels (like VLAN or EoIP) to pass multicast data over the routed network and use IGMP-proxy. Regards, Janis K. ////// when this feature will be !? how long to wait ? I will remind you on...

kemerovo

+1 for IGMP snooping

kemerovo

Where Janisk says that the status of IGMP snooping has been upgraded from "never-ever" to "maybe in a future version" . . . in 2012. 4 years have passed , but this feature has not implemented in ROS . a lot of people waiting for the implementation of this , but there is no infor...

kemerovo

If you want one box that does it all, then apparently, that box isn't made by Mikrotik.

do not abuse the forum if you have nothing to say on the subject issues

kemerovo

My mindset: If you need a router, use Mikrotik. If you need a switch, use some other vendor.

I do not want to use 2 or more devices from different manufacturers , I want to use one that will satisfy my need

kemerovo

You have to wait and read forum.

ok

001.jpg

4 years have passed on the situation has changed as you need to wait 10 , 15 or 20 years may be that developers heard the wishes of customers ????

kemerovo

Administrators why you ignore the wishes of customers ?

kemerovo

You don't. Wireless multicast helper is perfectly fine for home use where you don't usually have big number of wireless clients registered at the same time. Just please note that the multicast-helper=default (which is the default) currently means disabled . I know how to set up the equipment , but ...

kemerovo

Another way people deal with Multicast over WiFi is to ramp up the basic rate to a higher speed and disallow slow links.... I would think that unicasting the stream X number of times could get expensive on air time if lots of clients are subscribed to the stream. Although, I guess 10x 300Mbps trans...

kemerovo

+1 very need snooping for normally watch iptv

kemerovo

Dear admins when you give an answer on this subject ?

kemerovo

We plan to make a new Dude release this year, it should fix this, and many other bugs that have been gathered over the last years. Please post about RouterOS v6.33 and make new Dude posts in a separate thread . I hope in the new release will be finalized multicast and IGMP, I'm tired to use routers...

kemerovo

to my messages and no one answers , it's sad((

kemerovo

+1 hap ac
when add IGMP Snooping??

kemerovo

when will support igmp snooping ?

kemerovo

Прошу прощения за мой английский, буду высказываться максимально просто. К сожалению не владею английским. Всё валю на google переводчик если что. Не знаю, как в Европе и Америке,но в России довольно не плохо развито iptv multicast. Те средства обработки multicast трафика,что имеются в продукции Mi...

Search found 46 matches