802.11r for hAP ac2?

And IPQ-4019 supports it as well :sunglasses:
A couple of other devices besides AC3, Audience and Chateau who carry that one (but looking at product matrix, not that much benefit to gain there …).

4018 however, that’s another thing. Cap AC, Cap XL AC, AC2, wap AC, Wap R, … mighty interesting if that could be true.

Indeed, my Audience happily runs it. And my hAP ac2 is eagerly awaiting it.

That will never be possible! My hAP ac2 has only 1200 kB free space in a bog standard 7.9beta4 install. It will run out of space soon even without new drivers.
(note that old MIPSBE devices with 16MB flash have a lot more free space)
Only when offloading of space towards a USB stick would be supported, it could work. But even then it would probably require modularization of RouterOS v7 (so we can de-install unused features), also contrary to the current policy of putting everything in one package as much as possible.

Consider this:
despite the road which has been taken with ROS7 to be pretty monolithic (which at that point in time I understood) , that path has been left behind with wifiwave2, container, rose, zerotier … and whatelse will be coming.
So might as well go back to cutting the core down to the bare minimum as it was with ROS6.

Simple example: ROS7 has wifi legacy embedded which for quite a few devices is to be replaced with wifiwave2. Waste of resources, I would say.

Just my 0.02€.

Well, what I hate even more is that wifiwave2 cannot co-exist with existing wireless. I have a RB4011iGS+5HacQ2HnD. It has the resources to run wifiwave2 on 5GHz, but when I install it I will lose 2GHz, which I cannot do because I have some old slow stuff connected to that. If only the wifiwave2 would load first, detect the devices it supports, and then leave it to the existing wireless drivers to support the 2GHz interface…
And that for such a “flagship router”… I think MikroTik should give a mini-PCI card to those that request it, that replaces the 2GHz wifi with something compatible with wifiwave2.

Yeah, RB4011iGS+5HacQ2HnD is a funny one having having 2 different wifi environments.

Theoretically that swap of mini-PCIe card should be doable.
Practically, depends on the sales numbers, I guess.

There is nothing funny and nothing to hate but your own stupidity if made bad decisions knowing full well the limitations of older gen WIFI, after your first foray into mt wifi. I learned my lesson on capac and ended up with 3 thinking I was on top of the world…wrongo, so yes, hate but hate yourself for the second or third time you bought one. The fact that normis had to be politically correct above is very telling. No new features in OLD chipsets including OLD standards. BUT we will add new features by adding OLD standards into wifiwav2. Thats called progress. :slight_smile:

I am hoping my ax3 is not another paper weight!

It is time to add you to my foe list again, sore loser!

You can stop dreaming, like it was already said multiple times, ww2 package uses stock driver, which is very large. We can’t and wont take it apart, it would render useless our efforts to make stock qualcomm driver work in ROS. that was the whole point, take the driver and use it.

But but … Normis,
please enlighten me.

So are you saying that the wifiwave2 package uses the legacy parts to function ?
And there is no way to consolidate those ?

That’s a bummer.

Where did you see that Holve… WifiWave2 FULLY replaces old wifi. Its one or the other not both. As for RB4011 turn wifi off and get a capax :stuck_out_tongue_winking_eye:

Well, ww2 package includes stock drivers for all (new) chipsets. You could actually create ww2 package for each chipset which could fit.

So a “wifiwave2-lite” package for e.g. IPQ/4018/IPQ4019 devices with 16MB of ROM seems not be unrealistic to me at all

Read what I wrote above: a hAP ac2 has only 1200kB (1.2MB) of free space left with a bare 7.9 install of RouterOS.
That will fill up “soon” with the new 7.x releases and the additional new feature here and there that they introduce.

Well, the whole “wifiwave2-7.8-arm.npk” has

  • 10,1 MB (10.625.169 Bytes) packed
  • 25,0 MB (26.241.088 Bytes) unpacked

wifiwave2-7.8-arm\lib\firmware\IPQ4019 has

  • 1,30 MB (1.368.091 Bytes) unpacked

=> I still think you can pack all needed parts into an wifiwave2-IPQ4019.npk and still have some hundreds of KB left.

I don´t know whether MikroTik would have to pay additional licensing fees to the vendor if they release the wifiwave2 vendor based drivers for older devices like hAP ac, cAP ac…

Well, 802.11k, 802.11v, 802.11r for hAP ac2, cAP ac, wAP ac 1. gen, exists…
… with OpenWRT (officially) starting with release 22.03:
https://openwrt.org/toh/mikrotik/hap_ac2
https://openwrt.org/toh/mikrotik/rbcapgi-5acd2nd_cap_ac
https://openwrt.org/toh/hwdata/mikrotik/mikrotik_rbwapg-5hact2hnd_wap_ac

There is also a wireless controller: https://openwrt.org/docs/guide-user/network/wifi/dawn
Of course not as polished as CAPsMAN

While you are all talking here, 802.11r/k are already implemented.
https://help.mikrotik.com/docs/display/ROS/WifiWave2

But not on hAP ac2, cAP ac, wAP ac 1. gen as the previous poster writes!
You have announced yourself that MikroTik will abandon development for such units and will only go forward with wifiwave2.

Ah yes, wrong topic, sorry :slight_smile:
What I wrote previously is still correct. No new drivers for old chips.

And also no new drivers for old units. So no wifiwave2 for hAP ac2 and no usable wifiwave2 for RB4011 (because 2GHz does not work).
Essentially there is a cut in the MikroTik product line. Before that point you can have features like 4-address mode (transparent bridge) and modes optimized for Pt(m)P use (Nstreme, NV2), after that point you can have wave2 and 802.11k/r and maybe v.
There is no way of having them both, and there are only very few devices where the user can select which one they want.

We do not have “PER MODEL” packages. Only then we could do this. But change like that would require something like RouterOS v8, where all NPK package system is different, and we can make RouterOS-v8-hAP-ac.npk