I have problem with MTK’s PPPoE client. When I use ADSL modem on WindowsXP PPPoE client it conects instantly, but when I connect modem to MTK, can’t connect at all. But nothing. I get diferent IP address every second (10.65.64.xxx), and that is all i get from MTK. What else do I need to make this ADSL PPPoE to work, and what is the diference between Microsoft’s and MTK’s PPPoE…
Please help… Thanx…
Please… again… anyone… help… urgent…
Upgrade ? 
This problem have some old version of mikrotik
I can’t update v2.9beta15 - there is no newer version 
What does the log say? are you getting any errors? please post them.
Here is LOG:
pppoe-out1: initializing…
pppoe-out1: dialing…
pppoe-out1: terminating… - failed to authenticate ourselves to peer
pppoe-out1: disconnected
Again I must say that when I use this modem on WindowsXP’s pppoe it connects corectly. I am in agony 
What authentication protocols are you allowing? check them all (pap, chap, ms-chapv1/v2) the client will use the most secure method supported by the PPPoE Concentrator.
If you haven’t already double check your user name and password.
The PPPoE client settings are pretty straight forward..
Again nothin. Enabld all protocols. Even try system of eleimination of protocols. Double - no, triple chack my username/pass. I know that PPPoE should be easy to set, but… Maybe Telekom Serbia is doing something to us, and disabling linux logging. Win logging is still doing great…
I realy don’t know what to do
Is it posibile that there is no answer to my problem. I know that PPPoE used to be simple to adjust, but… Anyone have another idea…
Go back to 2.8.x - see if you have the same problem.
Yes, same problem with 2.8.26 and 2.9.16beta. Our TelecomSerbia is using username to find out where to route packets. Example: user@verat.net, user@beotel.yu, user@sezampro.yu… In my opinion the problem is with that extension after username. While analysing WinXP log, when i send my username, TelecomSerbia’s spliter or whatever recognize @xxx.xxx and route my packets to specific ISP. In my case, thet provider is verat.net. So when i send username@verat.net telecom route me to “veratadsl” service and then verat.net took over connection and it works. But with MTK I don’t even get “veratadsl” service name. That service name is in my case something else. I was thinking that is the problem with verat.net ISP, so i called other ISP and they gave me test account, but same problem…
I will try tonight to use SuSE and Mandrake as PPPoE clinet and see if the problem is with Linux…
leave service name empty and enter the user@verat.net in the username field. then it will work.
Normis, You think that I didn’t try that 
OK, it is working under SuSE 9.2… What now… Does MTK’s PPPoE entirely support RFC 2516??? Or, maybe not 
I have same problem but with wireless ISP. Under Win XP it works without anything just create new PPPOE connection and user and password. Under Mikrotik it says dialling and that is. Version is 2.7.14 and nothing happens.
Best regards
be healthy
Gaby !!!
OK MTK, again me with this informations:
PPPoE on TelekomSerbia’s ADSL is workin with WindowsXP, SuSE9.2, SuSE9.3, m0n0wall router OS, Ikarus router OS, Madrake (Mandriva) 10.2
In every of this OS it is enough to simply enter username/pass and it connects to ISP (tryed two diferent ISP), but with MTK - not working
I am doing the following:
/interface pppoe-client add interface=ADSL-lan name=user@verat.net password=password disabled=no
And the answer is:
pppoe-out1: initializing…
pppoe-out1: dialing…
pppoe-out1: terminating… - failed to authenticate ourselves to peer
pppoe-out1: disconnected
I have even tryed to play with adding other parameters like ac-name, service-name,…
And then, is it posibile for MTK’s creators to take a look again at the source code of PPPoE-client and solve this problem…
edited
not correct. like this:
/interface pppoe-client add interface=ADSL-lan user=user password=password disabled=no
no @'s please.
Ok i do it like this but nothing happens. Can someboady tell me for what is the profile. When I create a pppoe-client interface it creates with the default profile, but when i read the manual i thik that profile is about pppoe-server - not for client. I can post sniffed packets from PPPOE interface.
Be healthy
best regards Gaby !!!
in service fill in the same thing as your username.
but keep in mind username is like this username@PROVIDER
you HAVE to put the provider name in capital.
ans for auth only chap and pap are needed.
Normis, I think that You just solved the problem. In Serbia you have to enter username@isp.net, so our Telecom Serbia could with that @isp.net route trafic forward to ISP. Then there is another authentification at ISP which check your username and let you pass by and use internet.
Telekom Serbia did this because they have monopol and want to have total contol over Internet and voip.
If I want to use another ISP i simply change usename and isp.net but @ sign have to be there…
Please could You solve this…