ARP poisoning problem

RouterOS General
1

I’m using ROS 3.28

My hotspot clients seem do not have arp-reply from hotspot gateway.

Here the case:
One of my client (Computer A) using static IP 192.168.1.1
Other client (Computer B) that eventually using static IP with the 192.168.1.1 as gateway, have mac-address of Computer A instead of hotspot interface mac-address. If Computer B using gateway other IP other than existing one on the network, it works fine (because it have hotspot mac-address in the arp table)

Seems that mikrotik’s arp poisoning to client not powerful enough.
Any idea to solve this problem?

Regards,
Brian

2

Let me simplified this.

Hotspot should be reply any arp-request from client computers with hotspot mac-address.
What happen if the real owner of IP address replying also (in case the IP address is used by a computer on the same subnet)?