Difference Between " walled-garden " and "walled-garden ip"

RouterOS General
1

hi all
:smiley:

What is Actual Difference Between " walled-garden " and “walled-garden ip” in HotSpot Service ? :open_mouth:

Please guide me

2

/ip hotspot walled-garden - Walled Garden rules at HTTP level (DNS names, HTTP request substrings)
/ip hotspot walled-garden ip - Walled Garden rules at IP level (IP addresses, IP protocols)

http://wiki.mikrotik.com/wiki/Manual:Hotspot_Introduction#Configuration_menus

3

so your mean is that " in walled-garden we don’t care about IP and we just focus on HTTP REQ and DNS "

is that all?

4

yes, depends on whether you want to specify DNS names, or IP addresses

5

I have problem with " walled-garden " and “walled-garden ip”

I have a file server in other network and File Server located in front of Mikrotik Hotspot

and I have many Hotspot User in my network.

for Allow them to use file server in other network I insert the File server Traffic in " walled-garden " and “walled-garden ip”

I haven’t problem . And my Hotspot User can reach File server Without Authentication in hotspot.

BUT

when my users Login in hotspot and then, them make Request for reach To file server , this traffic goes to Hotspo settings and set bandwidth setting to those traffic :frowning:

please help

I want to do something that my clients reach the File Server with Unlimited Bandwidth Any way.( if them Authenticate Or didn’t Authenticate)

6

That has nothing to do whatsoever with the walled garden. The walled garden doesn’t deal with rate limits.

Read this: http://wiki.mikrotik.com/wiki/PCQ_and_Hotspots,_and_exempting_upstream_resources_from_rate_limit

7

Oh :frowning:

please some one help me

I couldn’t Understand your material :frowning:

this is my diagram , please help me

if you need more information please say to me

thanks

8

Hi,

You can use packet marks from firewall mangle to give free access to this destine.

Thats the best way to solve this, ok?

9

actually I write a mangle Rule in "ip firewall Mangle " but it can’t work :frowning:

please write your suggestion for my diagram in command line :confused:

thanks for your help

10

please some one help me

HELP

11

Taken directly from the manual I posted:

/ip firewall mangle
add chain=prerouting in-interface=LAN
dst-address=10.0.0.0/24 action=mark-packet
new-packet-mark=exempt-up
add chain=postrouting out-interface=LAN
src-address=10.0.0.0/24 action=mark-packet
new-packet-mark=exempt-down
/queue type
add name=exempt type=sfq
/queue tree
add name=hotspot-exempt-up parent=global-in
packet-mark=exempt-up queue=exempt max-limit=1G
add name=hotspot-exempt-down parent=global-out
packet-mark=exempt-down queue=exempt max-limit=1G

Replace the 10.0.0.0/24 address with the IP address of the server you want unlimited bandwidth to, and replace the “LAN” interface name with the name of the interface the Hotspot runs on.

12

thanks a lot

thank you