Double QoS

[mobilexpi]

Hello,
I’m implementing QoS on my RB450G, I’ve a 8Mbps pipe and I want to serve 16 clients.
I’ve used NetworkPRO tutotial and looks like it works fine when I’ve multiple clients (example, when I set maximum bandwidth to 200Kbps, and I use 180Kbps in one client, the second client has a good latency). BUT the first client has horrible latency, I’ve created simple queue for clients, is it a possibility to create a second Prioritization to each client (not only for the whole network).


Thanks

[Sanity]

@mobilexpi

Hello,
I’m implementing QoS on my RB450G, I’ve a 8Mbps pipe and I want to serve 16 clients.
I’ve used NetworkPRO tutotial and looks like it works fine when I’ve multiple clients (example, when I set maximum bandwidth to 200Kbps, and I use 180Kbps in one client, the second client has a good latency). BUT the first client has horrible latency, I’ve created simple queue for clients, is it a possibility to create a second Prioritization to each client (not only for the whole network).

Thanks

Drop the simple queues, put up a queue tree. Use a master queue for the output and PCQ to distribute the bandwidth between clients.

[kirkian]

@mobilexpi

Hello,
I’m implementing QoS on my RB450G, I’ve a 8Mbps pipe and I want to serve 16 clients.
I’ve used NetworkPRO tutotial and looks like it works fine when I’ve multiple clients (example, when I set maximum bandwidth to 200Kbps, and I use 180Kbps in one client, the second client has a good latency). BUT the first client has horrible latency, I’ve created simple queue for clients, is it a possibility to create a second Prioritization to each client (not only for the whole network).


Thanks

Hello,

You set Max-Limit to 200kbps on your “globlal” queue?

I have asked the same in other two topics without a good answer.

It seems that is not possible. Many people thinks that is priorizing traffic, but is not doing.

[mobilexpi]

Hello,
Thank you for your help. I’ve removed the Simple queues. I’ve created two mangle rules:
Add chain=forward src-address-list=basic_client_list action=mark-connection / new-connection-mark=basic_client_conn passthrough=yes
Add chain=forward connection-mark=basic_client_conn action=mark packet / new-packet-mark=basic_client_traffic passthrough=no

I’ve also add the two clients to an Address List named "basic_client_list

When I’m moving traffic looks like the Mangle rules work, cause data and packets value change.

But, when I’m implementing the Queue Tree it doesn’t work.
I see no packet or Bytes change, I’ve applied the following Queue Tree rule (for testing proposes I limit only upload), on Queue Tree:
Add name=“Total_upload” parent=internet queue=default priority=1
Add name=“basic_client_upload” parent=“Total_upload” / packet-mark=basic_client_traffic queue=PCQ_up_180 / priority=4

On Queue Types, I created one PCQ Type with 180Kbps (Limit 50/Total Limit 2000) and Classifier=Src Address.

I also have a QoS Prioritization rules and they work fine, but not the Total Upload Queue Tree.

@kirkian, now I’ve not setup the Max-Limit on the Global Queue, but still not working

Any idea?

Thanks

[kirkian]

@mobilexpi

Hello,
Thank you for your help. I’ve removed the Simple queues. I’ve created two mangle rules:
Add chain=forward src-address-list=basic_client_list action=mark-connection / new-connection-mark=basic_client_conn passthrough=yes
Add chain=forward connection-mark=basic_client_conn action=mark packet / new-packet-mark=basic_client_traffic passthrough=no

I’ve also add the two clients to an Address List named "basic_client_list

When I’m moving traffic looks like the Mangle rules work, cause data and packets value change.

But, when I’m implementing the Queue Tree it doesn’t work.
I see no packet or Bytes change, I’ve applied the following Queue Tree rule (for testing proposes I limit only upload), on Queue Tree:
Add name=“Total_upload” parent=internet queue=default priority=1
Add name=“basic_client_upload” parent=“Total_upload” / packet-mark=basic_client_traffic queue=PCQ_up_180 / priority=4

On Queue Types, I created one PCQ Type with 180Kbps (Limit 50/Total Limit 2000) and Classifier=Src Address.

I also have a QoS Prioritization rules and they work fine, but not the Total Upload Queue Tree.

@kirkian, now I’ve not setup the Max-Limit on the Global Queue, but still not working

Any idea?

Thanks

Please, read this topic where is my configuration where my Queue Tree of PCQ queues works fine, but not the Prioritization traffic queues like i want.

I mark connection types on forward, and traffic(icmp,sip,etc) in prerouting.
So, when i create the queues, for download the queue is on my local interface, for upload my public interface.
For prioritization traffic “global in”.

Please tell me how did you priorize your traffic.

Regards from Argentina!

and..sorry for my english

[mobilexpi]

Hi kirkian,
I will try with prerouting instead of postrouting, I hope it works
About the QoS, I use the NetworkPRO article (check Mikrotik Wiki) for QoS, I’ve applied rules for HTTP, VOIP, DNS, P2P, etc…and looks like they work…but not individually, just for the whole network, latency problems in user connection when he is downloading something continues.

A todo esto, también hablo español…sería genial si podemos comunicarnos, si quieres me puedes enviar un mail a salvadorb en el correo de google.

Saludos

[kirkian]

@mobilexpi

Hi kirkian,
I will try with prerouting instead of postrouting, I hope it works
About the QoS, I use the NetworkPRO article (check Mikrotik Wiki) for QoS, I’ve applied rules for HTTP, VOIP, DNS, P2P, etc…and looks like they work…but not individually, just for the whole network, latency problems in user connection when he is downloading something continues.

A todo esto, también hablo español…sería genial si podemos comunicarnos, si quieres me puedes enviar un mail a salvadorb en el correo de google.

Saludos

Mobilexpi ya le envie un correo.