hAP ac 802.11ac mode compatibility issue

Hi, I just got my new hAP ac router. And I notice it have a huge compatibility issue with my 802.11ac devices

There are no other 5GHz router around me, so the air is clear.

When I put the router to 802.11ac mode, I got following speedtest result:

Intel AC7260 (on laptop): ~30Mb/s
HTC Nexus 9: ~130Mb/s
Huawei Honor 6: ~ 44Mb/s

When I put the router to 802.11n 5GHz mode, I got following speedtest result:

Intel AC7200: ~180Mb/s
HTC Nexus 9: ~180Mb/s
Huawei Honor 6: ~44Mb/s


Seems both my laptop and nexus 9 table have some issue with hAP ac, which can’t get a expect speed.

Have anyone get the same issue?

Update:

Tried 6.34.2 w/ wireless-cm2 and 6.35r12 w/ wireless-rep

No difference between these two versions.

Update again:

Tried use some download tools to “benchmark” the wireless speed.

And I found out the low speed will keep for like 30 second, after 30 seconds, the 802.11ac wifi speed will go up to 180Mb+
(My broadband limit is 180Mb+, so don’t know what’s the real limit)

I didn’t try downloading something for more than 30 seconds but I witnessed the same problem.

Both laptops had some Intel AC wifi cards. Tried it with two different hap AC routers and speeds didn’t go above ~25mbit.
On 2.4Ghz network they got much better results.

i think the problem are not with 802.11ac devices in general

the problem is with that intel 7260 NIC

in my experience i have same problems with intel 7260 no ac version some driver versions give better performance than others

will be a good idea to explore the specific topic of performance with intel 7260 NIC, i have found rb951G do not perform well with this clients

But this didn’t explain why Nexus 9 also do better on 802.11n rather than 802.11ac

When using this intel card in other OS, the problem is gone, I think this could be related to the Windows driver:

https://communities.intel.com/message/361773#361773
https://communities.intel.com/message/215068#215068
https://communities.intel.com/message/293550#293550

Seems like Intel released 7260.HMWWB.R version (.R stands for revised) that “fixes compatibility issues”. Maybe someone could test with that card?

Intel WIFI cards are very popular, though not terribly reliable.

I have several here. After a tx power bug persisted through three hardware revisions I quit running Intel wireless cards.

We just made additinal tests. A few laptops with these Intel cards showed terrible performance even on other manufacturer AP devices with the same chip as the hAP ac. The same “other” APs showed good performance from Macbooks which have Broadcom chips. So at the moment this looks 99.9% Intel card issue.

Hi normis,

I had ask Dell to send me another Intel 7260ac wireless card and a Broadcom wireless card for testing.

Do you mind let me know which router you had test with Intel wireless card? So I can feedback the result to Dell together with my result, therefore Dell and Intel can start to solve the problem.

The old Intel bug was Windows only. Linux worked fine.

If you can try Linux on it, that would likely help narrow down the issue between hardware and software.

Not sure if the AC card will be supported by a live CD though, so it might take a bit more commitment than burning a CD.

We have managed to adjust RouterOS to these Intel cards. Soon we will release rc version where in wireless-rep package test fix for this problem will be included.

:confused: Already ask Dell replace the WLAN card to Broadcom one. Can’t test with it anymore.

We have fixed this in rc21. Please note that we are aware about issue only with Intel cards but it might be the same problem also with other vendor wireless equipment:

http://www.mikrotik.com/download
*) wireless-rep - fixed speed issue when connected with Intel 802.11ac


Note: Change is included only in wireless-rep package.

Looking into this issue

Inviato dal mio XT1562 utilizzando Tapatalk

Test hAP ac now with wireless-rep and latest RouterOS RC with intel ac 7260 .
Wifi speed around 250-300 mbit with 80 mhz channel. issue fix.

Will the fix for Intel ac clients be applied to the wireless-cm2 package?

If we will not find any more issues with the wireless-rep package we might merge the wireless-rep package into the wireless-cm2.

Bravo. Very good idea. Please keep it.