[hAP ax^3] Problem with Brother DCP T510w and some Sonoff devices

Hi guys

I upgraded my router os do version 7.20.4 after that my older devices stop working. They cannot obtain IP adress from DHCP and on Wireless page on WinBox shows, show TxRate:

Up to upgrade router os printer and sonoff device works fine without any problems with connect & obtain IP address.

I try to downgrade to 7.20.2 but its not working with this procedure:

  • Upload older version to root directory
  • Pass command /system/pakcges/downgrade
  • After reboot still newer version is:

Please and me some advice, it’s a lot of problems for me.

best regards

Did you upload all listed packages with their lower version to Files ?
All has to match or it will not pass.

Yes it helps, os now is in 7.20.2 but it not help with wireless problems.

Still printer cannot obtain IP adress and shows slow speed.

I think the probem is with compatibility on wifi, it use 2.4 band and some bands.

My config wifi 2.4 is simple without any additional settings:

Check security settings.

I have printers unable to use WPA3, some even only WPA.
Some IoT devices even barf when there is anything else then WPA on that SSID.

Another reason why I avoid wireless for printers like the plague ...

Just to be sure, can you move further down to 7.19.6 ?

On security tab there are nothing:

I can move to older version but where can I find it, microtik webside don’t show older?

Get link for 7.20.6.
Change to 7.19.6

https://download.mikrotik.com/routeros/7.19.6/routeros-7.19.6-arm64.npk

Do similar for wifi-qcom package.
https://download.mikrotik.com/routeros/7.19.6/wifi-qcom-7.19.6-arm64.npk

As a test, can you set the 2.4 GHz WiFi to ‘b/g’ only mode?
For ESPEasy I always advice users to test in b/g only mode, as these do not know about newer features like band steering and WiFi mesh features (and other features introduced in ‘n’ mode)

What I often see happening with ‘modern’ access points is that they quickly force a disconnect to let the node try to reconnect either on 5 GHz band, or some other WiFi mesh access point. And other disconnect reasons like 4-way handshake error, etc.

If you force the node to connect using 802.11g mode, then all those newer WiFi features are not trying to mess up your connection.
If you can’t set it on your node, then maybe set the access point to only advertise ‘b/g’ mode.

I don’t know if this also disables other features of the access point, but at least it will help you diagnose the issue a bit more.

@TDer In 7.19.6 has only this option, what should I choose:

@holvoetn My base software is 7.7.

Can I put line 6.49.x to my router ?

AX devices don't have option to choose b/g AFAIK.

They also come default with ROS7.
You can not go lower then factory version.

There is ‘ax’ on 2.4 and ‘ax’ on 5 GHz (also called “WiFi 6”). Just like there is ‘n’ on both frequencies.

So pick ‘2 GHz G’ as option.

N.B. ‘g’ is quite a bit slower. 54 Mbps.

Sorry about no answer for long time.

It works, so what I did:

  1. Reset router to factory settings
  2. Install 7.7 Version - baseline with wave2 not wifi-qcom
  3. Upgrade to latest wave2 stable version
  4. Configure router to my own setting from microtik quick-set
  5. Set on Brother side use DHCP istead of Static IP

When you decide to try upgrading again, I’m interested what went wrong as I also have AX^3, still on 7.19.4 though.

I upgraded my router os do version 7.20.4 after that my older devices stop working. They cannot obtain IP adress from DHCP

Configuration and logs are essential to begin troubleshooting. It would be worth sharing full configuration and logs as very first step. As first sight wireless configuration is ok while DHCP server configuration needs an attention.

They cannot obtain IP adress from DHCP and on Wireless page on WinBox shows, show TxRate:

does this device have action:accept on the “Access list” tab? How many devices are connected to that wireless interface at a time?

Up to upgrade router os printer and sonoff device works fine without any problems with connect & obtain IP address.

Are those devices successfully connected to 5GHz while older devices on 2.4GHz only end up on Registration List but can’t get DHCP address lease? Do these interfaces share the same subnet? How large is this subnet? How long is lease time? How many addresses are available to give?

All this devices work without any issue with software up to upgrade to 7.20.x with new look&feel interface.

Something went wrong with compatibility on 2.4 with b/g band.

All things as access list, subnet size are standard done via Quick Set wizard.

My thought this issue is linked with:

  • wifi-qcom
  • some problems on N band because b/g is missing in this software

So now I have 7.12.1 software installed with wifiwave2 and is working fine.

1 Like

Hi, It fixed printer problems but son-off cannot connect to WiFi. It tries to connect with 2.4G and in logs there are several tries:

There are some reason:

key handshake timeout.

Any suggestfion ?

regards

Current 2.4G config is:

On 2.4GHz radio I'd definitely go with channel width only 20MHz ... 2.4GHz band tends to be crowded and with only 20MHz channels things will be slightly better (better chance of finding channel with only mild interference, 3dB higher Tx power also helps) and it's more standard (up to 802.11N it was only option in 2.4GHz, legacy devices might freak out if they see features they don't understand). The "freak out" stance also applies to any other modern features, such as WPA3, GCMP, FT or anything newer than device's own 802.11 generation.

Also beware that some clients associate more than only SSID to the WiFi PSK stored. When settings change (such as encryption type, e.g. WPA -> WPA2 or even WPA3), then it might be necessary to "make them forget" the WiFi network and re-enter WiFi password.

Some people get around these problems by adding a slave interface with different SSID and different (legacy) security parameters ... tailored for those legacy (IoT et.al.) devices. Unfortunately that's not a solution for radio features (channel width, radio standard) because they are shared by all wifi interfaces running off the same radio (master and all slaves).