Customer intending to put a few IP (MPEG4) video streams over a number of MT radio links in series (perhaps up to 4 hops).
Likely to be any issues doing that (i.e. the half duplex radio, daisy chained) ?
Distances are not enormous and there will be no interference because of where these are going in.
Total bandwidth on link not an issue, i.e. <20Mbps.
By default our radio config is WDS bridged AP / WDSstation and the radio links will be separate P2P i.e. no “multiple client” associations, and using high gain antennas to keep the RF clean.
We are using Nstreme.
Would appreciate any advice from people familiar with daisy-chained MT links.
We have done this with triple-hop links, all configured with multi-radio units in AP - station relationships. There were no issues - other than the cameras that output mpeg4 tend to be cheap. Have never tried anything using single-radio mikrotik boxes.
Just some quick testing you might be interested in. I might be able to add a few more hops to this in a week or so if you are interested…I’ve been curious about this myself I’m posting this to show what you lose with hopping with single radio links, and not the actual bandwidth these particular radios can pass.
Boards are WRAPs@233MHz with CM9@36Mb and -70dB or better signals in the 5.3GHz band. The boards are downclocked from 266MHz to 233MHz (due to heat and the local climate) and the bandwidth does get reduced by a noticable amount at this slower speed.
[ test server ] -------- [AP1] ← - → [AP2] ← - → [AP3]
Bandwidth tests are with a Mikrotik on the test server (the bandwidth test client), which is wired to AP1 via 100Mb ethernet. The bandwidth server is the AP itself (which skews these results some). All 3 APs are bridged WDS with mode=ap-bridge with static entries. All OS versions are 2.8.28.
Speeds are based on values for the 10 second average after about 30 seconds. Ping times are based on a count of 25 pings. This network was idle when these tests were run.
Server <— AP1 UDP: 27Mb, TCP: 21Mb (ethernet)
Server —> AP1 UDP: 35Mb, TCP: 19Mb (ethernet)
Ping: min/avg/max = 1/1.2/2 ms
Server <— AP2 UDP: 18Mb, TCP: 14Mb (1 Hop)
Server —> AP2 UDP: 21Mb, TCP: 13Mb (1 Hop)
Ping: min/avg/max = 1/1.2/2 ms
Server <— AP3 UDP: 10Mb, TCP: 9Mb (2 Hops)
Server —> AP3 UDP: 10Mb, TCP: 9Mb (2 Hops)
Ping: min/avg/max = 2/2.0/3 ms
I would expect you could nearly double these speeds if a Routerboard 500 or better were used. I ran some similar tests awhile back with Prism2.5 cards and noticed similar losses at each hop (after 5 hops, we had roughly 768K and 20ms pings IIRC).
can I have an idea of how do you put a video stream on the network, I mean how do you proceed in streaming a video (is this tv channel, movies, etc..), which machine is used etc… thanx
I’m posting this to show what you lose with hopping with single radio links, and not the actual bandwidth these particular radios can pass.