mark connection on p2p all is broken in RC7?

Hello there,

maybe somebody can help with this: marking connection with p2p-all has worked very well with RouterOS 5.
When I updated to RouterOS 6 this stopped working on my RB493G.

So I wonder: is this a know bug?

I have tested with bittorrent btw.

Thanks!

Kind regards,
Daniel

My connection marks and packet marks also fail under RC7.
Reverted to RC6 and it is ok.

I posted that one in the RC7 release topic but no reaction…

Thanks, so I am at least not alone :slight_smile:

Hopefully Mikrotik will spot it and take care of it!

It seems fixed in rc8, at least my routing mark problems.
gosi: you should try again…

Thanks for the heads up. The RC8 isn´t public yet it seems. At least the link on mikrotik.com still shows RC7 :wink:

It was public, but now withdrawn due to some certificate problems. RC9 is on the pipe.

nice :slight_smile: Oh well, I guess I will wait then for the release of RC9 …

Is there some kind of channel to get notified about release candidates? Besides checking the website from time to time?

you can subscribe for email notify on the bottom of this page: http://www.mikrotik.com/download

or if you want to test versions before they are released, email support and you will get them in your mikrotik.com account (and some additional emails)

Thanks! Well, I saw RC9 was available today, installed it, but seems like the P2P marker still in fact is broken.

what kind of program are you using it for testing the matcher? let us know, so we can try to repeat. is it some bittorrent program? which one?

I am watching the queues in winbox, see screen shot attached. As you can see, only my normal traffic queues are filled at the moment,
using the IP->Firewall with “Mark Connection” and “Mark Packet” to put the packets in the according queue (2nd screenshot)

I am running rtorrent on a linux box inside of our network.
Bildschirmfoto 2013-02-11 um 11.47.17.png
Bildschirmfoto 2013-02-11 um 11.43.19.png

If I change the IP->Firewall rule to mark not by traffic type, but IP address it works again. So generally the marking seems okay, just the P2P filter is obviously broken at least for bitorrent.
Bildschirmfoto 2013-02-11 um 11.58.22.png

So actually I have made a work around now, by just marking all the packets from the server and putting them into the users_p2p queue,
that still works, as the screenshot shows.
Bildschirmfoto 2013-02-11 um 12.28.32.png

does not working on CCR rc 7, rc 8, rc 9 :frowning:
проблема 2.png

Thanks for confirming this @Masyanich!

We have confirmed it as a bug, thanks for letting us know. We will fix it.

Tested with RC10 today and it works again. Thanks!