I cant keep firewall address lists for any time beyond a reboot ?!??!
I cant keep logs internal to the box on a sd card ?
I cant read/write anything from a script to a sd card ?!?!
omfg… The whole reason I bought a 450G was to do this
DD-WRT and Open-WRT this is just normal.. I cant believe it…
If this is true then Mikrotik is SADLY lacking in even basic functionality.
Im stunned…
ok then… writing to NAND is obviously not a good idea, so there is no way to keep a system log beyond a reboot without using some outside computer to do SNMP or logging ?
I am just amazed… If this is true, man am I going to be vocal about this being added as a new feature. This cant be very hard to add. You just add /micro-sd/ to your file path.
That was the first thing i tried. I assumed it was not working as no files were created in the micro-sd directory. I looked with ftp and with winbox. Nothing.
No logging file is created in the micro-sd directory.
I can log in via FTP and see the directory, place files in it, I can see the files I place in the micro-sd directory from winbox files but No logging files.
No logging files appear anywhere. It does however seem to retain the log between reboots ?
If I omit the micro-sd path I do see logging files in the main NAND file listings.
Well… If you have rules that detect bad guys and you add them to a “bad guys” address list and it reaches a large number of these bad guys, it would be a shame to just dump all that acquired data on a reboot.
However, being a newbie, I suppose thats a bad idea to read/write firewall address lists from a SD card because of speed ?
I understand I would be wearing out the SD card..
I large number of fun firewall rules would keep list of IP addresses and its a shame to dump these each time you reboot.
Much like the logging. Good to keep this data around.
YES I understand I could do all this and more if I set up another computer to SNMP and do firewall stuff… But hey, these are ruff economic times and I just dont want to deal with another computer.
AND…
I was stupid and did not realize that I needed VERY specific MicroSD cards for my RB450G. It was clear that my WallMart special PNY 2GB was NOT working correctly. It was weird, I could FTP to and from it with no problem at fairly good speeds. I dropped 1GB in and out of it… About then my RB450G started rebooting. After much soul searching I determined it was the *^%#$@% MicroSD card.. ( sigh )
So its going to be a bit before I can retest logging on a MicroSD card cuz the one I got now causes rebooting.. Must get new one…
Anyone have a CHEAP card I can get that is known to work on the RB450G ? The cheapest one on the known good list is USD$20 + shipping.. Some well known one that you can get anywhere would be good.