Mikrotik QoS HTB exemple 2 wrong ?

Hi,

I’m very confused about documentation on the wiki and I’m having a debate with 3 persons. Here’s the link : https://wiki.mikrotik.com/wiki/Manual:HTB. If you check Exemple 2. Is it me or the answer is wrong :

Result of Example 2
Queue03 will receive 2Mbps
Queue04 will receive 6Mbps
Queue05 will receive 2Mbps
Clarification: After satisfying all limit-ats HTB will give throughput to queue with highest priority.

To my understanding, queue03 and queue02 are the same “level” because theire parent queue is both queue01. Queue03 have limit-at of 2 and priority 3. Queue02 have a limit-at of 4 and the priority is undefined. Let’s say undefined mean 8 (default in RouterOS). To me, it would queue03 will receive 2mb garanty then queue02 will receive 4mb garanty. Then, because queue03 have a higher priority then queue02, queue 3 will receive the remaining bandwidth. So answer would be :

Queue03 will receive 6Mbps
Queue04 will receive 2Mbps
Queue05 will receive 2Mbps

I’m wrong ?

yes you wrong, queue 4 will get all left to 10mbit : 2 + 4 = 6.

Could you elaborate ?



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk