OSPF + Simple Queue on Head Router Issue

RouterOS Forwarding Protocols
1

I have a straight forward OSPF network similar to the diagram below. R1 = CCR1036 R2 & 3 = RB2011

We are NATting at head router (R1) for 210.13.1.0/28, 172.16.1.0/16 and 192.168.1.0/24. I call these client nets.

I am trying to do all of the shaping for the three client nets on R1 with simple queues but it’s not working correctly. When a client simple queue is enabled on R1, for instance a 15/5 simple queue for 192.168.1.10 (under R3), the speed tests are all over the map and mostly 3-5Mbps. If I disable the R1 simple queue, full bandwidth is available. If I move the simple queue to R3 and disable it in R1, it works correctly.

I’d like to shape all clients on R1. Am I missing something? At first I thought it was firmware 6.37.1 on all routers so downgraded to 6.36.4 but same issue.

Likely a dumb question but frustrated. Thx.

2

Can you post results

queues export

just confirm there is no natting between routers on lan side. Also cinfurm yiu not running any firewall rules on r2 and r3

3

Thanks for the reply.

No firewall rules on r2 & r3.

NAT is setup on R1 for subnets (client nets) that are on R2 & R3. For example, NAT is set on R1 for subnet 192.168.1.0/24 which is on R3. No NAT entries set on the R2/R3 routers.

4

Can you show export of your queues and queue type on r1
Also confirm you not running faster on r1