Agreed. The link would work fine with a lower gain antenna.
The only way I’d use something that strong for a link that short would be in a horribly noisy area, and I’d still turn the TX down quite a bit. Ideal signal is in the -50s to -60s, I’ve got plenty of 54Mb links @ -75.
We mostly using high quality parabol antennas for PtP links even for short links with reduced power settings.
So you have less noise form back and sides.
You can run two antennas back to back with same frequency.