Hello everyone,
I'm asking for support from the forum because I'm having an unusual situation and would like some debugging suggestions.
I basically have an NNI kit with a carrier; all connections on that port are in QinQ mode.
I have a bridge that all the access VLANs participate in, so I can use PPPoE on the bridge.
Everything appears to be working properly.
When a client authenticates for the first time on the PPPoE server, it works perfectly. As soon as I reboot the PPPoE client router (e.g., TP-Link), it no longer reconnects.
The log shows that user XXX has disconnected from the PPPoE server, but I have no further attempts to reconnect.
Whether restarting the client, disabling the VLAN, or something else, it doesn't reconnect until a random amount of time passes (random, because it's usually a few days), and then it reconnects, repeating the same behavior.
I have version V. 7.20.1, but I haven't had a chance to update it yet because it's in production, and before doing so, I wanted to see if there was a foundation.
In the past I had that problem as a user, and it had nothing to do with the ISP or their PPPoE device, but instead it was caused by the carrier equipment which was snooping on the PPPoE requests to add/delete some info and it kept state of the connection.
Whenever I disconnected the PPPoE I had to keep it disconnected for some time before attempting to re-connect, or it would not come back up. RouterOS is persistently trying to connect whenever the PPPoE client is down, and there is no holdoff or backoff that can be configured.
I wrote some scripting to disable the PPPoE client for a minute or two before re-enabling it whenever PPP went down, and it fixed the issue. Recently I tried without that and the problem is no longer there, probably the software in the carrier network has been fixed.
On this bridge, configured as above, the pppoe server runs with the profile I showed above.
Essentially, I think I'm missing the "Horizont" configuration to avoid micro-loops between individual clients.
/interface/vlan
0 R costumer-VLAN-0296.3996_000008 1500 enabled 3996 service-VLAN-0296
1 R costumer-VLAN-0296.3997_000014 1500 enabled 3997 service-VLAN-0296
4 R service-VLAN-0296 1500 enabled 296 sfpplus12_ACCESS_L2_PORT
/interface/bridge/port
11 costumer-VLAN-0296.3396_000008 NNI_BRIDGE
12 costumer-VLAN-0296.3997_000014 NNI_BRIDGE
Since access is delivered in QinQ mode, I loaded the Service VLAN and registered the various Customer VLANs of the individual users on it, which were individually added to the bridge to receive pppoe.
Does anyone have an example of a Horizont configuration for this type of approach?