RB751U-2HnD as wireless bridge has unstable wireless connect

Hi,

I have a trouble with Mikrotik RB751U-2HnD as wireless bridge.
From time to time wireless connection is gone, I can see that Rx column shows 0 while Tx has jumping numbers.

Access point TP-Link TL-WR1043N configuration:
Channel: 1 (checked with neighbors as less interferent)
Mode: b-g-n mixed
Channel width: Auto
Max Tx rate: 300 mbps
Security: WPA-PSK / AES

Mikrotik RB751U-2HnD configuration:
/interface wireless> print
Flags: X - disabled, R - running 0 R name=“wlan1”
mtu=1500 mac-address=00:0C:42:E1:CA:6F arp=enabled interface-type=Atheros 11N
mode=station-pseudobridge ssid=“belkin3” frequency=2412 band=2ghz-b/g/n channel-width=20/40mhz-ht-below scan-list=default wireless-protocol=802.11 antenna-mode=ant-a wds-mode=disabled wds-default-bridge=none wds-ignore-ssid=no bridge-mode=enabled default-authentication=yes default-forwarding=yes default-ap-tx-limit=0 default-client-tx-limit=0 hide-ssid=no security-profile=default compression=no

Ethernet port eth1 and wlan are connected into bridge.


I have Linksys E2000 with Tomatousb firmware in wireless bridge laying at same table as Mikrotik, works as a charm without any complain.
Linksys has ~150 Mbps wireless connection. Produces internet speed around 40 Mbps download and 7 Mbps upload.

My MyBook directly connected to wi-fi from the same place in the house has less performance: 24 Mbps and 7 Mbps.


I would appreciate your ideas and comments.
Thank you.

During experiments for last several hour I found:
connection loose caused by channel width set to “Auto” at the TP-Link AP.

Changing transmission mode and channel width and corresponded changes to the Mikrotik wireless card gave me this result:

G-only 20MHz - 17/9 mbps
N-only 40Mhz - 10/7 mbps
BGN-mixed 40 Mhz - 13/7 mbps
BGN-mixed 20 Mhz - 22/10

I assume that in the channel width auto mode Mikrotik can’t “understand” current correct width? Did I miss some configuration setting?

Current configuration “BGN-mixed 20 Mhz” is the best I can get for know, but it’s the way slower then play laptop connection to wireless network?
Not talking about Linksys mentioned above.

Why such a big difference?
Can I increase connection speed on Mikrotik? External antenna? Configuration tuning?

Ok, after reading this posts:

http://forum.mikrotik.com/t/rb751u-2hnd/50470/18
http://forum.mikrotik.com/t/rb751u-2hnd/50470/18
http://forum.mikrotik.com/t/poor-performance-with-a-rb411a-r2n-in-n-ap-bridge-mode/32430/1

I understood that it is the nature of hardware. Too bad I didn’t read that before the buy. I’m disappointed.

Thank you for your “response”.

check what data rates the RB751 had when it connected with Auto channel width and check the registration table signal tab to see if it used the ht40 rates.
What signal level you had when you were doing that.
What CPU usage you had during the test?

It worked for two days and now I tried to tune some values. After that wi-fi died. I reseted configuration but no luck - wireless connection established and Tx goes but Rx is 0.

I tried just station mode and Rx = 0. Should it move even if it will not bridge laptop request, right?
I managed to ping AP couple of times and that’s it. Result is attached.

I tried change channel width at AP again from 20 to 40, to Auto, tried BGN-mixed, G-only, N-only like in the first post and RB751 connects all the time but Rx rate is 0.

About signal: I took RB and my laptop and went closer to AP, to different places in the house but Rx is still 0.

CPU usage during speedtest was less then 20%, usual level is 7%.

Is it possible that receiver or one of the antennas is damaged?
Screen shot 2012-01-20 at 22.48.45.png
Screen shot 2012-01-20 at 22.48.45.png

make support output file during the time when it isn’t working and send it to support@mikrotik.com

Hi

Is there any solution for RB751U-2HnD wireless problems? I’ve sold about 10 units and at least 5 users complains about they wireless clients are disconnected often, more than one time per day. Every router with this “effect” runs with latest version of ROS, every setup use all default values and only country was changed to estonia for using regulated limits. I’ve waited this router very long time and now very pity to hear such complaints :frowning:

There’s problem with the wireless driver. We (and many others probably) have send tons of supout’s to MT support.
I really hope one day they come with a decent wireless driver in the firmware so these devices finally become stable.
So far, the only solution is…disable the wireless and use an external AP.

This is really good solution - disable the wireless…

Was any feedback or promises published from a MT side?

Please ask the clients to make support output file from the router after they have disconnected/reconnected and send to support@mikrotik.com

You asked a solution… So far, this is the only working solution I can give you :slight_smile:

Feedback on MT 's side, Yes, please send supout and try new ROS version :slight_smile:
But for what it’s worth, it’s not solved yet, but getting better on each ROS release so far. So we’re still hoping…

Any news on this being fixed or at least being worked on?
MikroTik, are you able to reproduce it?

Deleted because not related.

Dobby,

We had +/- 50 in the field. Not one was stable with wireless enabled. Disabling wireless and adding an extra ubnt AP solved the problem. This ain’t an interference problem…

Deleted because not related.

Hi,

These were all indoor regular hotspot setups, never more then 8-10 concurrent users. We noticed if the client signal was a little weak, the wireless part on the 751 soon started to behave unstable (crashing device, no more throuhput on wireless, unable to connect to it, etc etc) From ubnt we used Picostation M2H to replace the wireless part of the RB751, no more issues since.

kind regards