I looked into the firewall, but since I am still learning MikroTik, and using this to be more knowledgeable with networking, I’m at a bit of a stand still.
I suggest setting up a log capture for each site to determine what is going on. It could be SSL/TLS1.x issue. It could be a DNS issue. We simply don’t know until we can get more information.
See about capturing the logs or use wireshark on the host machine to pull a packet capture. We can help more once we get additional info.
I don’t know how I overlooked this, but my subnet mask was set to 192.168.1.0/8 instead of 192.168.1.0/24 which is what I thought it was in the first place. Issue resolved, I am finally able to access these sites.