Vlans and network broadcast

Hello I have a bridged network with many vlans between the first router and the clients. IPs are assigned /30 ex. Network: 10.10.10.0/30 between the first router and the router customer.

My simple question is this: if the devices are very numerous in the same bridged network even if there are the vlans, may be a broadcast storm problem or not.

Thanks cetalfio

IMHO it heavily depends on how much is “many” :smiley: (e.g. probably 50 vlans are ok and 1000 are bad) and it’s also important what devices are in the middle of the path. If you have powerfull and smart switches with storm control protecting from mad/faulty client device, you can probably sleep happy.

I wonder your addressing is private or you are wasting a bunch of IP with /30 :smiley:

Grazie bajodel,

currently we have vlans for wireless bridges but I thought to create vlans also for customers but the devices number is too high, I understand that is not a good idea, some other idea?

cetalfio

  1. How much broadcast do you have now?
  2. Are cpe on your exclusive/full control ?
  3. Describe briefly your core network..
  4. Is actual cpe addressing (/30 mentioned) private/public?

The problem of the broadcast we are considering because the number of customers is increasing considerably. Our network is private and only we work on it. The CPEs are now 400 and IP address are private.

Our choice of network bridge is because we have only one PPPoE server and we want to avoid complicated configurations to work with MPLS on network routed or something like this.

We are a small WISP and we are considering how to adapt our network while the number of customers becomes greater.

At the moment we have a single fiber link so we have no need for any special routing protocol.

Thanks for your advice.

cetalfio

It’s not clear to me how your network is working now. You said about /30 networks (layer3) and in the last post you spoke about a PPPoE server (layer2 technology).
Your CPEs are doing pppoe over your core device ? If yes, why are you assigning a /30 ?

Each VLAN is its own broadcast domain so VLANs can actually help to determine where a broadcast storm is emanating from.

If considering changes it would be worth considering how you control customer traffic as it ingresses into your backhaul network.

Bridged networks can work very well but to remain manageable they need traffic control points and the ability to diagnose under fault conditions. Some large routing / switching suppliers offer equipment which provides the necessary layer 2 controls for ISPs but solutions in RouterOS tend to be more ad hoc.

MPLS/VPLS doesn’t have to be too complicated and can offer benefits even with ~500 subs. Whichever way you go, give yourself controls!

Switch from bridged to routed network.