They should also be logged with some details, so check if packets are going the right way, i.e. via WAN interface to client’s IP address. If they do, then router is sending replies back to client correctly. And if they don’t arrive, then something must eat them somewhere between you and client. But it’s not easy to diagnose it when the path is not under your control.
is this the proof that dns replay made out on WAN interface, i logged something from the step1 and its like this:
step1 output: in (unknown 0) out: ether1-Wan, proto UDP, my dns server public IP address :53 → remote dns client that im using :59363, len 168
Tnx, ISP is telling me that they are not blocking anything, but 4 different client IPs cant receive DNS replay…i guess i will speak with them again.
sindy
July 26, 2018, 11:33am
44
replay = proigrati ponovo,
reply = odgovoriti (ili odgovor)
I’m a bit nervous about the firewall log showing the packet but the torch not, I don’t remember whether you did a sniff on the interface.
Where exactly (to which table & chain) have you placed the rule which has logged that packet?
CZFan
July 26, 2018, 2:09pm
45
Can it be that the “Torch” screen update time? i.e. between updates this happened hence did not show?
I finally got an answer from different section of ISP, and they give me the tech prospect which saying that they are blocking source port 53 from clients in order to maximize security…
So 3 times i was in contact with “some” technical support and they told me they are blocking nothing, but thats not the case…its really crazy when someone is not informed like that…