Hi, sorry for my english, my problem is How to make this: "Certain Bandwidth Equal Distribution between Users" in wiki there's no information or example, but i tried http://wiki.mikrotik.com/wiki/PCQ_Examples - Equal Bandwidth for a Number of Users - it's work, but my situation is - i have a Certain Bandwidth for my internet connection and i want equally distribute it among active users, ie if one active user, then his get full badwidth, if two active users, then they get full bandwidth/2 etc. Mikrotik routeros also make NAT for this users.

Please, give me right example of my situation or for "Certain Bandwidth Equal Distribution between Users".

Hi

I'd like to see the example of this too

thanks

OK I've found this "Equal bandwidth sharing among users" http://www.mikrotik.com/testdocs/ros/2.9/root/queue.php for ROS 2.9

I'm a bit confused now according to the above example it would be poss to share 10mbps between say two users where one is having 8mbps and the other is having 2mbps but according to this http://wiki.mikrotik.com/wiki/PCQ the two users would both be getting equal 5mbps queues. This would become a problem with say 50 users divided up equally...

does that make any sense.

thanks

OK I've found this "Equal bandwidth sharing among users" http://www.mikrotik.com/testdocs/ros/2.9/root/queue.php for ROS 2.9

I'm a bit confused now according to the above example it would be poss to share 10mbps between say two users where one is having 8mbps and the other is having 2mbps but according to this http://wiki.mikrotik.com/wiki/PCQ the two users would both be getting equal 5mbps queues. This would become a problem with say 50 users divided up equally...

does that make any sense.

thanks

Dont be confused, it DOES make sense, in this exmple it says that the total bandwidth will be equally divided for all users, if user A is downloading 2Mbs (which does not mean he only gets 2Mbs, it means that the remote server is giving him max 2Mbs) so user B can get the rest of the bandwidth (Again, he can get up to 8Mbs if he could).

in simple words, if your ISP gives you 10Mbs of bandwidth this does NOT mean you always getting 10Mbs, it can vary UP TO 10Mbs

OK I've found this "Equal bandwidth sharing among users" http://www.mikrotik.com/testdocs/ros/2.9/root/queue.php for ROS 2.9

It's very bad example and it doesn't work with NAT. It works only with routing, not NAT. In my case this example doesn't work.

I'm found next way to realize equal distribution with NAT and PCQ:

- use GLOBAL-OUT for outgoing traffic in Queue Tree and mangle forward

- use Simple Queues without specified Max-Limit, Limit-At, Target and Distination addresses. Specified only interface or use interface all. - Why so - because

if your ISP gives you 10Mbs of bandwidth this does NOT mean you always getting 10Mbs, it can vary UP TO 10Mbs

and

Note! If your ISP cannot guarantee you a fixed amount of traffic, you can use just one queue for upload and one for download, attached directly to the interface:

/queue tree add parent=Local queue=pcq-download packet-mark=users
/queue tree add parent=Public queue=pcq-upload packet-mark=users

- for PCQ-Limit use big values, for example for 7500kbitps downstream I'm use PCQ-Limit = 1920 and pcq-rate=0, maybe it's wrong, but i can't found examples how to realize equal bandwidth sharing with NAT.