After reading the forums I finally decided to bite the bullet and purchase a Draytec Vigor 120 DSL modem. I want the PPPOE client on the RB2011 so I can port forward from the ISP's IP address and so I don't have two traverse two NATs.
No issues getting the DSL portion working - set the VCI to 32 (CenturyLink/Qwest) and it trained up to a 20 mbps/892 kbps connection. Clicked the button to forward all PPPOE traffic and spent four hours with the RB, with a Windows 7 PPOE client and an older D-Link router trying in vain to get the user name and password to work.
When I run a PPPOE scan (I am using ether6) I can see the Vigor and I can see the connection.
I can use the Vigor's client to make a connection too - so I know the password and user name are correct.
So I am assuming I am missing some setting on the Vigor and it's not doing the PPPOE passthrough.
Any suggestions from folks who have working Vigor modem setups?
P.S. When are we getting a Mikrotik with an integrated DSL modem. I see posts back to 2007 from Mikrotik folks saying it's in the works.