Static Routing without NAT

RouterOS Beginner Basics
1

Hi,

I followed this tutorial: http://wiki.mikrotik.com/wiki/Manual:Simple_Static_Routing
I would like to configure a similar network, but with one router:

Now all PCs have access to internet.
What I am trying to achieve is PC1 and PC2 to have connection to VOIP adapter.
I did it using NAT masquerade, but based on this topic NAT should be used when it’s really needed.

In my situation I should use routes.

I tried the following, but as you can see the route is blue…

Thank you in advance for any help!

EDIT:

The device from LAN2 actually is not a regular PC, it’s a device (VOIP adapter) for which I can’t indicate the default gateway (the normal gateway for PC3 would be 192.168.3.2).

I tried everything and only Masquerading (with “Out Interface” - LAN2) will make a connection from LAN1 to LAN2.

Can anyone confirm this is the only solution for my case?

2

you dont need add this rule because is there.

check your firewall rules allowing traffic between your network.

3

I have EDITED the first post.
yes, you are right! I just forgot to mention another detail, and this is important:

PC3 from LAN2 actually is not a regular PC, it’s a device (VOIP adapter) for which I can’t indicate the default gateway (the normal gateway for PC3 would be 192.168.3.2).

I tried everything and only Masquerading (with “Out Interface” - LAN2) will make a connection from LAN1 to LAN2.

Can anyone confirm this is the only solution for my case?

4

yes, is the solution, no problem