I have a MAC address I want to block from either getting an IP address from the DHCP server, or from transiting the network via internet.
I added this rule at the top of the Firewall rules:
Your rule denies forwarding (only).
Your request was to stop DHCP lease, and transiting the network to Internet. The last of the 2 requirements is in your firewall rule.
You did not specify how the device connects , so there may be possibiliies at the incoming interface.
I think you should add at least a specific DHCP lease for that MAC with “block access” in the DHCP server.
Personally I would stop the device at the connection, for wireless you have the “access list” TAB where you can remove the “authentication” and “forwarding” for that MAC.