Consolidate 3 switches into 1

I would like to ask -

I have 3 units of 8-ports layer-1 switches (other brand, with different subnet/IP(s) running).

I would like to use a 24 port Mikrotik router/switch (e.g. CSS326-24G-2S+RM , or CRS326-24G-2S+RM) to consolidate them, to free electricity sockets (due to data center socket limitation).

May I:

  • Delete Mikrotik default configuration.
  • Port 1 for PoE-in power (no IP assignment)
  • Assign IP to port 2 for admin management
  • Create a few IP firewall rules for its router protection.
  • Create a bridge for port 3 - port 8
  • Create a bridge for port 9 - port 16
  • Create a bridge for port 17 - port 24

Then, shall it be OK?

Thank you very much for your advise/comment.

Regards
George

CRS3xx running RouterOS only provide wire-speed switching by using hardware offload on one bridge. Use a single bridge with VLANs configuring the groups of access ports, e.g. port 3-8 VLAN100, port 9-16 VLAN101, port 17-24 VLAN 102.

CSS devices have a fixed single bridge. You can either use VLANs as with CRS devices, or port isolation https://help.mikrotik.com/docs/pages/viewpage.action?pageId=76415036#CRS3xxandCSS32624G2S+seriesManual-PortIsolation

CSS series only runs SwOS which doesn’t work the way you described desired configuration.

CRS runs ROS and should be fine. However: only single bridge can be HW offloaded, if you use more bridges traffic of those will be handled by CPU (which in turn means that performance will be crap).

It is possible to “segment” a bridge to 3 partitions … and I can think of 2 ways:

  1. by using horizon properry of bridge ports … I’m not entirely sure tgat this is handled by switch chip so this way may degrade performance
  2. by introducing VLANs (albeit only internally to the device) and setting ports appropriate PVID value. This kind of setup should definitely be HW offloaded by CRS326 you’re mentioning.

IMO going the way #2 above is the way to go. In this case, if port VLAN membership is properly configured (specially of bridge interface), only a tiny set of firewall filter rules will be necessary (if at all).

Some reading, useful for way #2 - not recipes, but good foundations to build your own setup. And probably in this order as well:
http://forum.mikrotik.com/t/routeros-bridge-mysteries-explained/147832/1
http://forum.mikrotik.com/t/using-routeros-to-vlan-your-network/126489/1

Piece of cake using a CSS326 using SwitchOS. You can segment it either with VLANs or Port Isolation. Either is very easy to set up.